Wednesday, December 02, 2020

How I drew and 3D printed a Southwold Railway van

The majority of the goods rolling stock on my railway has been bashed from LGB or HLW wagons and chassis to make them look more UK-based. As a consequence, most of my wagons are only vaguely representative of stock which would have run on an English three foot narrow gauge railway.

 

Since buying a (very) cheap 3D printer (under £80 new on eBay), ...

 

  ... I have been steadily developing my skills at drawing my own designs using TinkerCAD (see How I drew and 3D printed some window frames) which covers most of the basic techniques used in TinkerCAD. After having replicated the open wagons (see How I drew and 3D printed my own design of open wagon - pending) which I had constructed from my own resin castings (see How I made my third batch of open wagons) and a luggage van similar to those on the County Donegal Railway (see How I designed and 3D printed a luggage van), I decided to try something more challenging and, more importantly, based on a real prototype.

Drawings of the rolling stock on the Southwold Railway are reproduced in most of the books about the railway. I used those in The Southwold Railway 1879-1929 by David Lee, Alan Taylor and Rob Shorland-Ball, which I photocopied and enlarged. Using a couple of the known measurements on the drawing, I was able to convert all the dimensions into 15mm/1ft scale (1:20.3).

The first job was to draw the solebars for the chassis. The main beam was just an elongated cuboid.

The brackets at each end of the main beam were a couple more cuboid with domed rivet heads strategically attached.

Once one bracket had been drawn it was duplicated and 'Mirrored'. The brackets were then moved to the ends of the solebar beam and grouped to make a single unit. I find grouping objects at regular intervals to be useful as it means the unit can be moved or even re-sized easily.

 The W-irons were a couple of cuboid grouped together, one being rotated (by around 22 degrees I seem to remember). Once one was drawn it was duplicated and then mirrored. The axle box was drawn from four shapes; a (blue) cuboid, a (green) trapezoid (on page 10 of the Shape Generators tab), a (orange) cylinder and a (red) cuboid with smoothed edges. A short 3.5mm diameter vertical hole was formed in the back of the axle box using a cylindrical 'hole' shape for the end of the 3mm axle.

The leaf springs were overlapping 'ring' shapes which were bisected (with an cuboid hole).

The brackets for the leaf spring were made from an elliptical cylinder with a couple of domed rivet heads attached.

Once all the components had been assembled, additional ironwork was drawn on the solebar beam. The solebar was then duplicated and a brake lever added to one of them. This was constructed from a long thin trapezoid, whittled away with various curved hole shapes. The brake shoe plus its actuating arm was drawn separately so it could be glued in place once the wheelsets had been added.

Two spacers were then drawn to ensure the distance between the solebars was accurate for the Lilliput/Bachmann metal wheelsets I'd be using (60mm long for 45mm gauge and 44mm long for similar 32mm gauge wheelsets).


I tackled the sides of the van next - as these are basically a series of oblong boxes joined together. A cuboid formed the side, to which a couple of beams were added, top and bottom.

The divisions between the planking were created by placing a series of thin cuboid 'holes' at regular intervals (using the Duplicate and Repeat tool) across the side and then grouping them with the side to make the indentations.

The vertical beams were then added, together with the sliding door.

The planking on the door was then inscribed as above, ......

 ..... after which, the vertical beams on the door were added.

Angled sections were created above the bottom horizontal beam using wedge shapes, ....

.... and the bevels in the upper beams were made by cutting holes with cuboids which had had their corners rounded.

Finally, the ironwork was added in the form of corner plates and runners for the sliding door, rivets and a triangular canopy over the doorway.

The end of the wagon was created in a similar way, except that the curved section for the roof was made by slicing off a chunk from a large circular disk, made from a flattened cylinder.

 
 The edges of the end were shaped to allow the sides to be slotted into them.
 

Once all the pieces had been drawn, they were exported from TinkerCAD as .STL files and then imported into Cura to be sliced. They were then loaded into the printer and printed out.



Some wedge-shaped corner pieces were also drawn and printed, together with some curved roof supports (created by copying then van end into a new design and slicing its top off ).


The ends and sides were then glued together using thick superglue from the ToolStation website. The roof supports were also glued across the middle of the wagon.

The corner pieces were then glued into a place to act as supports for the floor, which was cut from a piece of 2mm thick plasticard (I could have drawn and printed it, but feel that it's a waste of filament to print out a piece of plain plastic sheet).

One of the solebars was then glued in place, having carefully measured its position (30mm from the centre line of of the floor)

Lilliput 32mm diameter spoked metal wheelsets were slotted into the axleboxes and the other solebar glued into place.

One of the spacer pieces was then glued across the middle of the wagon.

The brake block and hanger assembly was then glued to the floor of the wagon so it aligned with the relevant wheel behind the end of the brake lever.

10mm wide planks cut from 2mm thick plasticard were then glued to the roof. NOTE: I started from the outside edges and worked my way to the middle, so that I could be sure the overlap at the edges was correct. The final plank was cut to the correct size to fill the gap.

A 0.5mm sheet of plasticard was then glued to the roof to give it a smooth finish. NOTE: I cut the sheet larger than was needed and glued it carefully into place by applying liquid poly cement, starting at one side and then gluing the sheet into place in stages. Once the solvent had set, the excess plastic was trimmed off.

3D printed centre buffers were added to the headstocks.

The wagon still needs to have a paint-job (Halfords grey primer as the livery with black acrylic for the solebars).

I addition, I will attach my wire versions of LGB style hook and loop couplings - and then the van will be ready to enter service.

I must admit, I really like the compact nature of this van. It's much smaller than the vans which already run on my railway but I anticipate making a few more of these and steadily replacing my existing stock.

As you can see from the photos, I have done very little smoothing, filling and sanding on the parts. Considering the cost of the printer, I don't think the finish is too bad. 

For those interested in short-cutting the process and making their own models, I have uploaded the all the parts to Thingiverse.

Happy printing

To be continued ........ 

Monday, November 30, 2020

Progress Report 85

 Things have been surprisingly busy on the railway and associated areas considering the time of year! Most developments have revolved around 3D printing which, since I discovered the joys of creating my own parts in TinkerCAD, has become an important component in my model making arsenal.

 

A side issue has been various rescue schemes to help save the Garden Railway Forum, which was under threat of closure unless someone with the requisite IT skills could take over from the retiring previous Administrator. I'm pleased to say that it's closure has now been averted owing to the timely intervention of a fellow modeller with the right sort of skills, but insufficient time to manage its day to day running - more of that later.


Permanent way and Lineside

Level crossing gates

The proposed route of the Peckforton Light Railway would require at least six level crossings over minor roads and two under-bridges for major roads (see A tour of the hypothetical line). At present, there is only one level crossing actually modelled (see How I made a level crossing), so I plan to add at least two more. 


Some of the others will be "off stage" (ie in the section which presently lies behind the sheds) and two others will be represented by a single crossing on the section of track which is traversed twice (see A trip along the line).

I decided to draw the gates in TinkerCAD and print them out (see How I made my second batch of level crossings - pending). 

At present, I am exploring a way in which I can make the lamps operational with large LEDs and small button cells. The difficulty is modelling a simple switch mechanism which can be incorporated into the design.


Station nameboards

After watching some of my recent videos of the railway (eg see Excerpts from the running session), I realised that passengers might have problems identifying which through station they were arriving at. I realised I needed running-in boards at each end of the platform rather than just in the middle.

One of the features of TinkerCAD is that it includes a collection of letters and numbers in a variety of fonts and so, it was quite an easy process to design  nameboards; double-sided for stations with island plaforms ......

 

..... and single sided for stations with platforms on one side of the track.


These were printed-out .....


..... and painted in the default colours for the railway.

[Awaiting photo]


I usually deploy delicate items such as these at the start of running sessions. I often have to stand on platforms to mow the hedges which lie behind the stations.


Rolling stock

 PLR open wagon

 Most of the open wagons which run on the PLR were constructed from resin kits which I cast myself, using Hartland Loco Works (HLW) mini series wagon chassis (see How I constructed my third batch of open wagons).


These have served me well over the years but I was perturbed to find out that HLW has now ceased trading and so my source of cheap wagon chassis has dried up. There was nothing else for it, but to make my own chassis - drawn in TinkerCAD and 3D printed.


 

Having produced the chassis, the next logical step was to produce a body to fit on it. 

 

So, should any of my open wagons bite the dust, I now have a quick and easy method of constructing replacements.

 

Southwold Railway open wagon

Having replicated the design of the majority of open wagons (see above), I felt that I could improve on the design by making opens which were based on those which ran on the Southwold Railway (see How I 3D printed Southwold Railway open wagons). The first job was to design the wagon chassis.
 


After which the sides were drawn, printed-out and joined to the chassis.

[Awaiting photo]

I'm trying to decide if I should now start replacing all the open wagons on my railway with these more realistic alternatives.


Southwold Railway van

Having successfully modelled an open wagon, I realised that the early style of van on the Southwold used the same chassis and so, why not draw a van body to sit on the chassis (see How I constructed a Southwold Railway van)?

 

 I am presently drawing the larger modified version of this van and will be interested to see how they compare side by side (something which never happened in reality on the Southwold Railway).

 

I find the proportions of the vans very pleasing and so am trying to decide whether I should now start replacing some (or even all) of the vans on the PLR with these.


Southwold Railway coach

Of course, why stop at a Southwold open wagon and a van? I have always fancied constructing at least one of the Southwold coaches but have fought shy of tackling the six wheeled Cleminson undercarriage. The beauty of 3D printing is the ability to continually tweak drawings and designs until they do the required job. This suits my way of modelling perfectly - I am more of a trial and improvement modeller than a careful planner, designer and constructor. 


 The Cleminson chassis is a case in point. This has undergone at least three re-designs before it has reached its present state. I might even tweak it again to make further improvements.

 

However for now, it seems to be working satisfactorily. I need to give it a more thorough testing over the whole railway to be certain the design is effective but I am pleased with how it has eventually turned out.

For more information, see How I constructed a Southwold Railway six-wheeled coach.

Of course, the next item on the list ought to be one of the Southwold six-wheeled open wagons. Watch this space, as they say!

 

Other

Garden Railways Forum

I have been a member of the Garden Railways Forum since 2009 and have found it a valuable source of information, ideas and a place to seek advice on specific topics. When it was recently threatened with closure - the previous Administrator wanted to stop running it and, owing to its complexity, would only hand over to someone with equivalent or better IT skills - I explored creating an equivalent alternative. I even got as far as buying a similar domain name and creating a forum of the same design.


Fortunately, a fellow forumite with the requisite skills stepped forward, but only on condition that he would hand over the day to day running of the site to me and a couple of moderators.

 

So - I've ended-up becoming the joint Administrator of the forum. Fortunately, the two moderators are accomplished and conscientious and so I am hoping the forum will not take up too much of my time. After all, I have a railway to run........


Friday, October 16, 2020

Progress Report 84

The weather has been quite unpredictable since the last Progress Report. We have actually had a few days of warm and sunny weather but also some very cold, wet and windy spells. In this time, I took the opportunity to visit North Wales for a few days with a couple of mates and do some hill-walking, primarily to prove to ourselves that despite our age and decrepitude, our bodies were still up to it! Whilst we appreciated the sunny weather which gave us some magnificent views across the mountain-tops, .....

... it meant I was unable to use the these drier days to run a few trains. However, I did spend some time in the workshop and also managed one full running session.

 

Lineside

Boneworks

The Boneworks building is now, more or less (see How I constructed the Boneworks building), finished. 

Since the last progress report, I have finished off the painting and added 3D printed guttering and downspouts.
The building is now becoming part of the landscape, though I have realised I will need to install lighting in the engine house to allow the beam engine to be seen.
 
I am also intending to add sound effects by using a small MP3 player with sound effects recorded from the real beam engine in the bone mill in Stoke on Trent on which my model is based (See Creating sound effects with small MP3 players).
 

Rolling Stock

The luggage van for the railcar has now been finished off, painted and has entered service.
 
In addition, I have redrawn the components so all the additional detail, such as the strapping, hinges and door locking mechanism is part of the 3D printed components. 

I have also produced a 3D printed chassis, based on the dimensions of the Hartland Loco Works (HLW) chassis which forms the basis of many of my wagon builds.

HLW has now ceased trading and so it won't be long before stocks of their mini-series wagon chassis dries up. I can now run-off my own versions as and when I need them, either to replace wagon chassis which have become irreparably damaged. 
 

Operation

As indicated above, the September weather has been very changeable - which is not conducive to running a garden railway. Nothing is worse than clearing the track, an then setting out the buildings and rolling stock, only to find it starts pouring down with rain. I like to have at least two fine days in succession to ensure I have sufficient preparation time, running time and clearing-up time to enjoy a full operating session. I do run occasional trains in between full sessions but I don't find these anywhere as satisfying as running my railway as if it is the real thing.

 I have managed only one full operating session since the previous progress report. It gave me an opportunity to try out the boneworks at Bulkeley Station and to give the new luggage van a run on the rear of the ex-Clogher Valley railcar.